Bid due diligence: litigation checks before award
Procurement teams check bidders’ financials, experience and registrations. Litigation is often the missing check, and it can matter just as much: a contractor already in disputes with three other buyers, in recovery suits with its lenders, or facing an insolvency petition is a risk to the project, whatever its bid says.
Search each shortlisted bidder, its directors and group companies across courts and tribunals, read the orders in anything material, and record the finding against your evaluation rules.
Prices read from ecourtsindia.com on 15 November 2026.
Last updated: 15 November 2026
Key takeaways
- When: after technical shortlisting and before award, so the check is focused and proportionate.
- What: the bidder, its directors, its group companies and its past disputes with buyers.
- How to judge: by your procurement rules and the facts of each matter, not by the number of cases.
- Record it: keep the CNRs and the reason for each decision on the file.
- Cost: a few rupees per bidder in searches at the Enterprise base rate.
What should a procurement team look for?

- Disputes with other buyers: civil and commercial suits and challenges to arbitral awards involving other government bodies or companies. A pattern says more than any one case.
- Recovery suits and cheque bounce: lenders and suppliers suing the bidder point to cash-flow stress.
- Insolvency: a petition admitted at NCLT changes who controls the company and whether it can perform.
- Fraud or cheating complaints: serious, but allegations until decided. Read the order.
- Directors: disqualifications and defaulter list entries. See our director check guide.
How does the check work in practice?
- For each shortlisted bidder, list the company’s current and former names, its directors and its group companies, from the bid documents and the company registry.
- Search each name across district courts, High Courts and tribunals. Use facets to see the spread by case type and state at a glance.
- Confirm each case is the bidder’s own, not a similarly named company.
- Read the latest order in anything material, with the Court Order Summary API for a first view.
- Record the findings and the decision, with CNRs, on the procurement file. Give the bidder a chance to explain where your rules allow.
The same process for ordinary vendor onboarding, combining GST, MCA and court records, is in our vendor KYB guide.
Why arbitration records matter in bid evaluation
Because contract disputes increasingly end up there. Many works, supply and service contracts carry an arbitration clause, so a dispute between a contractor and a buyer often shows up in court only when someone asks a court to appoint an arbitrator, challenges an award or tries to enforce one. Our index holds 3,75,204 arbitration petitions and appeals (case types ARB_PET and ARB_A) across all years, with 1,01,024 still marked pending, and filings have roughly doubled since 2021.

| Filing year | Arbitration petitions and appeals | Change on previous year |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 19,197 | up 51% |
| 2022 | 24,986 | up 30% |
| 2023 | 26,453 | up 6% |
| 2024 | 32,519 | up 23% |
| 2025 | 40,477 | up 24% |
Three provisions explain most of what you will see on a bidder’s record. Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is the route to ask a court to set aside an award. Section 36 makes an award enforceable like a court decree once the time to challenge it has passed, and filing a challenge does not by itself stop enforcement unless the court grants a stay. Section 37 sets out the orders that can be appealed, including an order setting aside or refusing to set aside an award.
For a procurement team, the useful question is not “does this bidder have arbitration cases” but “against whom, about what, and who won”. A contractor that keeps losing awards to buyers, or keeps challenging awards it lost, is telling you how it handles disputes.
How to find a bidder’s disputes with other buyers
- Search the bidder as a party, then facet by case type. ARB_PET and ARB_A point to arbitration; writ petitions (WP_C) in a High Court can mean a challenge to a tender decision, a termination or a blacklisting order; CP_IBC means an insolvency petition at the NCLT.
- Look at who is on the other side. A run of cases against public sector undertakings, municipal bodies or state departments is more relevant to a public tender than disputes with private landlords.
- Use full-text search for context. Our search reads the text of uploaded orders as well as case details, so a phrase search such as “notice inviting tender” or “e-tender” finds High Court cases where the order discusses a tender. Since 2021 that phrase search returns 363 High Court records, 329 of them civil writ petitions. It only finds cases whose orders are indexed, so treat it as a lead, not a complete list.
- Check the directors and group companies too. A contractor can bid through a new entity while its sister company carries the disputes.
A scoring grid you can adapt
| Finding | Suggested weight | What to put on the file |
|---|---|---|
| Routine commercial suits, few in number, mixed outcomes | Low | Count, CNRs and a one-line note that they are ordinary for the bidder’s size |
| Arbitration award against the bidder in favour of another public buyer | Medium to high | The award date, the amount if stated and whether it was challenged under Section 34 |
| Repeated writ petitions challenging terminations or blacklisting | High | The buyers involved, the outcome of each and any order still in force |
| Insolvency petition admitted against the bidder | High | The admission order date and the current stage at the NCLT |
| Insolvency petition pending or withdrawn | Medium | Who filed, the claim if stated, and the bidder’s explanation |
| Criminal complaint for cheating linked to a past contract | Medium to high | The stage, whether charges were framed, and any acquittal or discharge |
What a clean record does and does not tell you
A bidder with no cases in our index is a good sign, not a guarantee. Some disputes never reach a court: they settle, or they sit with an arbitral tribunal that does not publish its proceedings until someone goes to court over the award. Some courts publish fewer orders online than others, and a company that has changed its name may appear under the old one. So a clean result should be recorded as “no cases found for these names on this date”, with the names you searched, rather than “no litigation”. If the tender is large, ask bidders to declare pending litigation and arbitration in the bid itself, and use the court search to test the declaration.
Worked example: three shortlisted bidders
Suppose a buyer shortlists three civil contractors for a road project. All three pass the technical evaluation. The litigation screen takes under an hour and costs a few rupees per bidder:
| Bidder | What the screen found | How it was handled |
|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | 14 cases, mostly recovery suits by and against subcontractors, two arbitration petitions it won | Recorded as routine for a contractor of its size |
| Bidder B | 3 cases, including an arbitration award in favour of a state road agency that B challenged and lost on appeal | Raised with the bidder; explanation recorded; evaluation committee applied the tender’s past-performance clause |
| Bidder C | 1 case: a Section 9 insolvency petition by a cement supplier, pending | Bidder asked for proof of settlement; petition later shown as withdrawn |
The point is not the count. Bidder A had the most cases and the least concern. If you work in banking or insurance rather than procurement, the same logic powers our KYC and AML litigation screening guide.
How should findings be weighed?
By relevance and by your rules, not by count. Large contractors are often party to many cases simply because they do a lot of work. A handful of ordinary commercial disputes may mean nothing; one insolvency admission or a string of terminations by other buyers may mean a lot. Procurement decisions should follow the rules in the tender documents and applicable procurement law, and a finding should be recorded with the reason it did or did not affect the evaluation.
What does it cost per bidder?
For a bidder with five directors and two group companies, eight searches cost ₹1.60 at the Enterprise base rate, and reading ten cases in full adds ₹5. Summarising five material orders adds ₹12.50. That is under ₹20 per bidder before GST, far less than the cost of a contract that fails mid-way. For the economics across workflows, see what court data costs.
Sources and method
- Prices from ecourtsindia.com/api/pricing, read 15 November 2026.
- The checklist is an illustration, not procurement or legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
How can a procurement team check a bidder for litigation?
Search the bidder’s current and former names, its directors and group companies across district courts, High Courts and tribunals, confirm each match and read the orders in anything material.
Which litigation matters most in bid evaluation?
Patterns of disputes with other buyers, recovery suits by lenders, insolvency proceedings and fraud complaints, weighed by your procurement rules and the facts.
Should many cases disqualify a large contractor?
Not by count alone. Large contractors are party to many routine disputes. Weigh relevance and seriousness, and record the reason for each decision.
How much does a litigation check per bidder cost?
Under ₹20 per bidder at the Enterprise base rate for searches, case reads and a few order summaries, before GST.
When should the check be done?
After technical shortlisting and before award, so the effort is focused on serious contenders.
How many arbitration cases are filed in Indian courts each year?
Our index shows 40,477 arbitration petitions and appeals filed in 2025, about twice the 19,197 filed in 2021.
Does challenging an arbitral award stop it being enforced?
Not by itself. Under Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, a Section 34 challenge does not make the award unenforceable unless the court grants a stay.
How do I find a bidder’s disputes with government buyers?
Search the bidder as a party, facet by case type, and look for arbitration cases and writ petitions where a public body is on the other side.
Important: This guide is published by Billion Insights Ventures Pvt. Ltd., the company behind eCourtsIndia. It is not legal advice. Court data shown here is a copy of public court records as read on the date stated at the top of this page and is not a certified copy. A name match is not identity, a pending case is not guilt, and a disposed case is a status, not an outcome. Prices, limits, counts and examples were checked on that date and can change. eCourtsIndia is a private legal-technology platform and is not affiliated with any court, the e-Committee of the Supreme Court or the Government of India. Found an error? Write to support@ecourtsindia.com.



